Tuesday, April 8, 2008

FLDS Raid

For anyone who has turned on the news in the past 24 hours, I'm sure you have heard about the raid on the FLDS compound in ElDorado, Texas. While there may be some shady things going on in secret behind those walls, this abuse of executive police and judicial power is frightening. More than 400 people have been taken from their homes based on a ridiculously broad warrant based on a call from a young girl that the authorities cannot find or even identify. However, the tension here is much deeper than the overreaching police in Texas. There is an interesting tension here between the interests of society and the interests of the family and parents. On this end, we have children who grow up within a society in which they are not given free agency to act and interact with society. I would argue that society has an interest in raising children and helping those children to become responsible adults within society, rather than isolated within a religious compound. However, on the other end, when you take the rights of parents out of the mix, you get a situation like Lexington, Massachusetts where teachers at a public elementary school were teaching children that homosexuality was the norm without any obligation to notify the parents of what was going on. So, while in the case of the FLDS raid, society does have an interest in these children's lives, the right of the parent cannot be totally taken away. Where do you stand? Leave your comments.

1 comment:

Buzz said...

I believe that when we as a society decide upon whose rights we may infringe, then we are headed towards a country based more upon intolerance and away from the fundamental beliefs of our country. America is a country that prides itself on religious tolerance, acceptance of differences, and its willingness and ability to work through differing opinions and beliefs for the greater good. Do I agree with the practices of the FLDS religion and way of life? No! Do I believe that this is reason enough to raid the compound in El Dorado? Again, my answer is no! However, there are certain issues of child protection which are raised whenever one talks about the FLDS religion and its practices of supposed polygamy. I will not delve into it all but children need to be protected, sometimes, even from their parents!